KUCHING: The outcome of the recently concluded Melaka state election should not be taken as a direct indication of how Sarawak voters will respond in the 13th Sarawak general election.
Political analyst Prof Dr Novel Lyndon said Sarawak had a distinctly different political environment, where voters placed considerable importance on local leadership, personal relationships, rural development, the Malaysia Agreement 1963 (MA63) and Sarawak’s autonomy.
“Based on my observations on the ground in Melaka and my understanding of Sarawak’s political landscape, political issues and voter expectations differ considerably between the two states.
“While national political developments can influence public discussions, Sarawak voters also place strong emphasis on local leadership, community relationships, development delivery, Sarawak autonomy and MA63.
“Therefore, PH’s defeat in Melaka should be treated as an important lesson rather than a direct indication of how Sarawak voters will respond in the coming state election,” said Novel, a political sociologist at Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia’s (UKM) Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities.
Novel said one of the key lessons from Melaka was the importance of candidate selection, stressing that political parties should prioritise loyal, locally rooted candidates who understood their communities and had a proven record of serving the people.
He said parachute candidates with little connection to local communities could struggle to gain public trust, regardless of their qualifications or political connections.
“Elections are not about ‘touch and go’ but about ‘touch and caring’.
“Political leaders cannot simply appear during elections, meet voters, make promises and disappear afterwards. They must continuously engage with the people, listen to their problems and demonstrate genuine concern, even when there is no election,” he said.
He added that his observations during the Melaka campaign showed voters were more concerned about the rising cost of living, employment opportunities, local development and the ability of political leaders to address their everyday problems.
National political issues alone, he said, were insufficient to convince voters if parties could not demonstrate their ability to respond to concerns at the grassroots level.
For PH, Novel said the coming Sarawak election could provide an opportunity to rebuild and strengthen its political credibility through committed local candidates, sustained grassroots engagement and a clearer understanding of the state’s needs.
He said voters ultimately judged political parties not merely by their national leadership or election promises, but also by the consistency of their presence, their understanding of local challenges and their genuine concern for community well-being.
“The Melaka election offers important lessons for PH, particularly concerning public confidence, grassroots organisation, political identity and the ability to deliver on promises.
“However, Sarawak should not be viewed simply as an extension of electoral trends in Peninsular Malaysia. Sarawak voters will make their decisions within their own political, cultural and development context,” he said.
Novel cautioned that repeated electoral defeats could also have longer-term implications for PH, potentially weakening its grassroots morale, public confidence and political bargaining position.
He said the central challenge for PH ahead of the Sarawak election was to demonstrate a clear understanding of local aspirations and offer credible representation capable of addressing the needs of the people.





